Rollup merge of #129938 - chancancode:patch-1, r=thomcc

Elaborate on deriving vs implementing `Copy`

I was reading this documentation and this wasn't immediately clear to me.

In my mind, it seemed obvious that a type can only claim to be `Copy` if the bits it is storing can be `Copy`, and in the case of a generic struct that can only be the case if `T: Copy`. So the bound added by the derive seemed necessary at all times, and I thought what the documentation was trying to say is that the custom implementation allows you to add _additional bounds_.

Of course what it was actually trying to point out is that just because you have a generic parameter `T`, it doesn't necessarily mean you are storing the bits of `T`. And if you aren't, it may be the case that your own bits can be copied regardless of whether the bits of `T` can be safely copied.

Thought it may be worth elaborating to make that a bit more clear. Haven't tested/didn't try to figure out how to render this locally. Mainly not sure if the `PhantomData` back link is going to just work or need some extra stuff, but I figured someone else probably could just tell.
This commit is contained in:
Matthias Krüger 2024-09-05 18:58:56 +02:00 committed by GitHub
commit 0db3932433
No known key found for this signature in database
GPG Key ID: B5690EEEBB952194

View File

@ -288,8 +288,19 @@ marker_impls! {
/// } /// }
/// ``` /// ```
/// ///
/// There is a small difference between the two: the `derive` strategy will also place a `Copy` /// There is a small difference between the two. The `derive` strategy will also place a `Copy`
/// bound on type parameters, which isn't always desired. /// bound on type parameters:
///
/// ```
/// #[derive(Clone)]
/// struct MyStruct<T>(T);
///
/// impl<T: Copy> Copy for MyStruct<T> { }
/// ```
///
/// This isn't always desired. For example, shared references (`&T`) can be copied regardless of
/// whether `T` is `Copy`. Likewise, a generic struct containing markers such as [`PhantomData`]
/// could potentially be duplicated with a bit-wise copy.
/// ///
/// ## What's the difference between `Copy` and `Clone`? /// ## What's the difference between `Copy` and `Clone`?
/// ///